By The Star Staff
The Puerto Rico Court of Appeals on Tuesday reversed a Court of San Juan ruling that in March disqualified a number of candidates from the Citizen Victory Movement (MVC by its Spanish initials) and the Dignity Project (PD) political parties for failing to collect endorsements.
The Appeals Court noted that the plaintiffs who filed the suit to disqualify the MVC and the Dignity Project candidates did not have legal standing nor did they demonstrate to the court that they had a sufficient connection to and harm from the law or action challenged.
“Having resolved that the damage for which the lower court recognized active standing to one of the plaintiffs and interveners is hypothetical, we resolve that they did not meet the requirement of having suffered a clear and palpable damage that would grant them standing to file the lawsuit,” states the Appeals Court ruling. “It is therefore appropriate to revoke the appealed sentence due to lack of active standing.”
The decision reversed a ruling that Judge Anthony Cuevas Ramos issued on March 21, thus paving the way for the MVC and PD candidates to run in the general election.
The plaintiffs from the Popular Democratic Party (PDP) made a significant move by announcing their decision to appeal the Court of Appeals’ decision to the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, adding a layer of anticipation to the ongoing legal battle.
Cuevas had disqualified the MVC candidacies of Ana Irma Rivera Lassén, who was running for resident commissioner, Myrna Conty Hernández and Mariana Nogales Molinelli, both of whom were running for at-large seats in the House of Representatives, and Senate candidates Rafael Bernabe Riefkohl and Alejandro Santiago Calderón. Cuevas also disqualified the Dignity Project candidacy of Stephen Gil Álamo for the District 38 House seat.
The MVC filed its appeal against the disqualification pointing to four alleged errors in Cuevas’ ruling. They also sought a window of opportunity to allow the MVC candidates to collect endorsements.
The appellate court decision was written by judges Félix Figueroa Cabán, Ana Mateu Meléndez, Fernando Bonilla Ortiz and Annette Prats Palerm after an oral hearing. One of the judges dissented from the majority opinion.
At-large PDP House candidate Jorge Quiles Gordillo said: “We respect the decision of the panel judges. However, we disagree with the determination and reiterate that the MVC and PD candidates failed to comply with the Electoral Code and the applicable regulations.”
“In conversation with our legal representation, and in defense of democracy and the uniform application of the laws, we are going to appeal to the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico,” he said. “Likewise, we insist that Judge Cuevas Ramos’ determination was strictly legal, which is why the Court of Appeals should have confirmed the Court of First Instance.”